How Each Type Handles Crushes
Developing a crush can be a harrowing experience for many people because of the intense emotions and the constant wondering about whether feelings are reciprocated. Here are some general descriptions that shed some light on how each type may handle a crush.
How Your Type Influences Attraction
Attraction and romantic interest manifest differently across personality types, largely due to differences in cognitive function stacks. How someone processes emotions, picks up on social cues, and decides whether to act on their feelings is deeply influenced by their dominant and inferior functions.
Feeling types (F) tend to be more immediately aware of their romantic feelings, though they may struggle with how to act on them. Thinking types (T) often need more time to recognize that what they are experiencing is a crush, sometimes rationalizing their feelings before acknowledging them. Extraverts typically express interest more openly, while Introverts may observe and analyze from a distance before making any move.
Guardians (SJ) tend to be traditional and cautious, Artisans (SP) are spontaneous and action-oriented, Rationals (NT) approach attraction strategically, and Idealists (NF) seek deep emotional connection above all else. Select a temperament below to explore the specific crush patterns for each type.
ISTJ
ISTJSince Fi is in the tertiary position, how ISTJs react to a crush will depend on their level of emotional maturity. They generally have no problem stating their opinions, but they do not tend to be open with their innermost feelings.
ISTJs who aren’t good with handling feelings and emotions will generally have difficulty making firm decisions. They may get stuck in denial for a long time. They may get stuck processing feelings and miss opportunities to act. They may worry about acting because of fearing what could go wrong. Generally speaking, it takes them a long time to work up their nerve, so they prefer to take small and gradual steps whenever circumstances permit.
ISTJs who are better with Te-Ne tend to be more assertive because they know how to plan well and march resolutely, step by step, toward their goal. Their way of talking about feelings is matter-of-fact and they prefer yes/no responses. They may take an ambiguous response as proof of disinterest.
From the other person’s perspective: It’s not easy to read the feelings of an ISTJ, unless they are very annoyed. Immature ISTJs can sometimes be too pushy or critical because they haven’t yet learned how to be sensitive and tactful. They can also be very rigid and stubborn, which makes it difficult to connect emotionally with them.
ISTJs prefer to use concrete and practical ways to show their love and care. They are good planners, organizers, and problems solvers, so they lean heavily on this skill set in relationships. Mature ISTJs are very helpful people because they love to use their extensive knowledge for good. They tend to be unsung heroes, as people overlook their quiet contributions. If an ISTJ is willing to help solve your problems or remove your obstacles, it could be that they’re simply doing it out of duty or discomfort with loose ends, so make sure that it’s only you for whom they’re willing to go above and beyond. If they like you, they’ll actively look for ways to be useful to you.
Because ISTJs tend to develop relationships very gradually, it is more efficient to simply ask them whether they are interested, but they may need time to reflect upon it if you have caught them off guard. Generally speaking, ISTJs don’t like improvisation, spontaneity, or the unpredictability of emotional conversations, thus, putting them on the spot could help to reveal how they really feel, in the event they lose their footing and filter. If an ISTJ behaves weirdly awkward or sheepish around you, you should wonder why. If you’re not comfortable confessing your feelings, build up a good friendship with them first. Hopefully, over time, they will feel more and more comfortable and eventually be open to talking about feelings with you without too much awkwardness.
ISFJ
ISFJISFJs generally fear rejection, so they are often not bold enough to express their feelings directly to the person, especially if they do not know the person very well. Those who are in touch with Fe-Ne may be more assertive and take the initiative to pursue a crush, in terms of dropping more obvious hints. ISFJs who have less developed Fe-Ne will be much more hesitant and timid, sometimes feeling paralyzed, sometimes proceeding extremely carefully with imperceptible steps. They may first learn about the crush from a distance or through mutual friends, if they cannot work up the courage to deal face-to-face.
ISFJs often struggle with emotional life because they are easily affected by the emotions of others. Generally speaking, ISFJs are independent in their own way and capable of taking care of themselves, due to being very practical people. However, when their focus is shifted onto another person in such a forceful way as can happen during a crush, they can lose their sense of stability. This produces anxiety and they will start to focus too much on the other person, thinking they can regain control over the situation. As a result, it is not uncommon for ISFJs to inadvertently lose touch with their own needs, emotions, and priorities and, instead, become obsessed with gathering every tiny detail about the other person.
From the other person’s perspective: You can tell an ISFJs likes you if you have felt a shift in the amount of attention they give you. Being adept at taking care of themselves and others, ISFJs often channel their feelings into thoughtful gifts and practical acts of service. It is also a significant sign if an ISFJ asks you for help with something, because they are usually self-sufficient and do not like the idea of burdening others. Some ISFJs may plan out a series of steps or challenges to test the waters, e.g., they may invite you out to group functions to see how often you attend, or they may do something slightly out-of-character or break their usual routine to see if you take notice of these small details.
Generally speaking, if an ISFJ wants to spend more time with you, chatting one-on-one, and they do little things to care for your well-being that they do not necessarily do for everyone, your chances are good. More mature ISFJs will make bigger and more obvious gestures, whereas less mature ISFJs may struggle with shyness/anxiety and behave more awkwardly or impulsively.
ESTJ
ESTJESTJs are generally quite confident people who communicate openly and straight-forwardly. How they handle feelings depends a lot on how they were raised. ESTJs who are quite used to emotionally supportive environments tend to be more sensitive, loyal, nurturing, and honorable because they have internalized those values and know how to find healthy outlets for their feelings. Those who were brought up in harsher or cut-throat environments tend to have a lot of difficulty processing their feelings and emotions, usually projecting them onto others through critical or aggressive behavior.
Si-Fi gives ESTJs a very good memory of past failures. If they have a painful history of heartbreak, a crush situation is likely to make them feel vulnerable, which would manifest as skittish or passive behavior. They may try to rationalize away the feelings. They may try to resign themselves to never acting upon their feelings. They may look for “signs” to determine whether the relationship is “meant to be” (and feel very low/high accordingly), never able to draw any firm conclusion.
More upbeat and confident ESTJs are usually quite forward and open with their flirting. They use Te-Ne very well to take advantage of flirting opportunities until the crush gets the hint and reciprocates. The more confident they are about the outcome, the more efficiently they move in for the kill.
From the other person’s perspective: Because of inferior Fi, ESTJs prefer to use actions or acts of service to express their care. They will display much larger gestures of generosity toward those in their inner circle (while easily dismissing everyone else). To them, relationships are an investment and, the more they like you, the more of themselves (in terms of time, resources, and energy) they are willing to share.
Very immature ESTJs often struggle to open up about their feelings, perhaps even avoiding feeling talk altogether. Their emotional unavailability often attracts certain feely types who are convinced there’s more underneath, but, in reality, there is no real depth there. These ESTJs are more likely to treat relationships as transactions or zero-sum games. They are more likely to suffer from paranoia and expect the worst of people. They are more likely to have a harsh, controlling, or critical attitude that makes intimacy very difficult.
Mature ESTJs generally jump at the chance to make themselves useful, thus, they love to be needed and asked for advice. However, their way of helping others often leads to them ignoring their own emotional needs for too long. Thus, the way into their heart is to find some way to serve or pamper them, as a way of showing how much you appreciate their hard work in keeping life well-organized and running smoothly.
ESFJ
ESFJESFJs tend to be polite and graceful in social situations and this can give the impression that they are very confident and well put together. However, they know how everyone is feeling except for themselves. It takes some time for them to go inside and get in touch with how they really feel, deep down. They can be slow to realize that they are crushing on someone and, when they are certain of a crush, they’ll fill up with strong feelings and emotions.
Mature ESFJs are better at managing their feelings and will use Si-Ti to try to analyze the situation and determine whether pursuing the crush is a good idea. But they can easily get stuck thinking about things in circles, or even accidentally convince themselves that they don’t have a crush when they do. This often leads them to consult with others and talk out their feelings at length, so sometimes it may be worth investigating what their confidants know.
Less mature ESFJs can feel quite flustered by a crush and this can result in them suddenly losing their social confidence in front of that person because they are not used to being so distracted by their own internal happenings. ESFJs are attuned to social status and have a keen sense of who holds more authority/power in situations. Thus, ESFJs who feel as though they have the upper hand will be more forward/bold about their feelings. But if they feel the other person is “out of their league”, then they will keep their feelings hidden or repressed due to lack of confidence or fear of rejection.
From the other person’s perspective: For less intuitive types, it may be hard to tell if an ESFJ likes you because 1) they can appear friendly to everyone, and 2) they themselves may not know how deep their feelings for you run. ESFJs tend to look for the good in people at first sight, so they can be very quick to like someone. This “like” can easily be mistaken as a crush, but it may not go very deep in reality. Some ESFJs may develop a crush just because they caught wind of someone liking them first, even though they never would have considered the possibility before that. In other words, ESFJs are suggestible, which makes it difficult for them and you to know their true feelings.
Once they are sure of a crush, less mature ESFJs might seem suddenly awkward or timid, maybe even avoidant, because they overanalyze their own behavior and end up tripping over themselves in (failed) attempts to control how they are seen by you. They may try to charm everyone around you, in order to catch your attention through showing off their social prowess. They may try to impress you by adopting your interests or hobbies, thereby creating opportunities to spend time together.
In pursuing a crush, mature ESFJs will usually pay more attention to you, make a point of remembering little details about you, dote on you, try to anticipate your needs, make doubly sure you are happy/comfortable, etc. Look at their behavior in relative terms to see whether they seem to be going that extra mile for you compared to other people. They will want to be near you, seek your attention or acknowledgement, and look for opportunities to show their affection for you in practical ways. Be sure to show appreciation for the nice things they do for you. They will start to doubt your feelings if you do not properly reciprocate their gestures in visible ways.